3 Key Differences: John Allan Architectural Design vs SF Structures

Last Updated: November 17, 2026

Quick Summary

John Allan Architectural Design leads on architectural design, planning permission and vision, while SF Structures leads on structural integrity, building warrants and load calculations. Most projects need both firms, and treating the two appointments as parallel rather than sequential avoids redesigns.

  • An architectural practice handles site survey, feasibility study, concept drawings and planning application support.
  • A structural engineering firm confirms a building will stand safely.
  • Running the two appointments sequentially rather than in parallel makes redesigns almost inevitable.
  • Ask each firm for a written fee proposal broken down by stage.
  • Integrated working earns its place on extensions, garage conversions, commercial projects and listed building work.
Architect or engineer first for your project?We combine architectural design and structural engineering in one team so your plans are buildable from day one.

Book a Feasibility Study

Table of Contents

John Allan Architectural Design vs SF Structures: A Direct Comparison

Architects lead on design, planning permission and vision; structural engineers lead on structural integrity, building warrants and load calculations. Readers comparing the two firms can read how architects and structural engineers differ in roles and services. Most projects need both.

Infographic comparing the architectural design process between John Allan and SF Structures at a kitchen table
Infographic comparing the architectural design process between John Allan and SF Structures at a kitchen table

What does an architectural practice actually do?

An architectural practice handles site survey, feasibility study, concept drawings, planning application support and building standards documentation. An architect may not confirm whether a wall can come out, so check this with the structural side of the project.

What does a structural engineering firm actually do?

A structural engineering firm confirms a building will stand safely.

How the two firms differ, side by side

Criteria John Allan Architectural Design SF Structures
Core discipline Architectural design and planning Structural engineering and calculations
Typical first task Site survey and feasibility study Structural assessment of a design
Best for Layout, extension design, conservation work Wall removal, load paths, structural integrity

Where the handover between firms goes wrong

The real difference shows up in the handover. An architect produces a layout, then the structural engineer explains the open-plan span needs a steel beam that changes the ceiling height. Treating the two appointments as sequential rather than parallel makes redesigns almost inevitable.

How to budget for home extension design fees

Architectural fees cover survey, concept design, planning and building warrant drawings; structural fees cover calculations and structural drawings. Ask each firm for a written fee proposal broken down by stage, and what happens if planning is refused.

What Is Included in Architect Fees Scotland?

Architect fees in Scotland vary by practice and project. The scope of what is included should be confirmed in a written fee proposal.

Scottish Government guidance on planning permission sets out the statutory stages an application passes through, which helps you see exactly where an architect’s fee is being earned.

What a typical fee breakdown covers

Our guide to architect fees for a single storey extension walks through a full breakdown, and our pricing page sets out what each stage includes.

Why the cheapest quote often costs more

The cheapest fee proposal is rarely the cheapest project. Where a practice has priced only for planning drawings and left structural work out, you will pay a second professional later. Compare quotes on scope, not on the total.

Benefits of Integrated Architectural and Structural Services

Integrated architectural and structural services mean one firm handles both design and structural engineering, so the layout is confirmed as buildable before it reaches planning: no gap between professionals, no redesign, one point of contact.

At Architectural Services Scotland, this is the model we have worked to for 40 years, since our founding in 1985. Our team combines architectural design and structural engineering within a single firm, so designs are structurally robust and buildable from the initial sketch.

What integrated working changes in practice

If your project involves removing a wall or opening up a floor plan, our structural wall removal service shows how the two disciplines combine. When you are ready, contact our team directly.

Is integrated working right for every project?

No. Integrated working earns its place on extensions, garage conversions, commercial projects and listed building work.

What about planning and building warrant approval?

No practice can guarantee approval, and any firm that promises it first time is worth a second look. Integrated working aims to reduce the risk of rejection and delay by keeping drawings consistent with the structural reality. Planning permission and building warrant are separate processes with separate requirements, and the Scottish Government building standards guidance explains how building warrant applications are assessed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need both architectural design and structural engineering services for a home extension?

Most home extensions require both. An architectural designer handles the layout, planning permission and building warrant drawings, while a structural engineer calculates load paths, beams and foundations. Hiring them separately means coordinating two schedules and paying two sets of fees. An integrated firm covers both under one roof, so the design is buildable from the start and you avoid the cost of redesigns when structural issues surface later.

What are the benefits of an integrated design and engineering approach?

Integrated architectural and structural services remove the gap between concept and construction. You get one point of contact, fewer delays waiting for information to pass between firms, and a design that is checked for structural integrity before it reaches building control. It also reduces the risk of expensive changes on site, because the engineer has reviewed the drawings at sketch stage rather than after planning approval.

How much do architectural design services typically cost in the local area?

Fees vary with project size, complexity and whether structural calculations are included. A straightforward garage conversion costs less than a two-storey extension or listed building renovation. Rather than quote a figure that may not match your project, Architectural Services Scotland publishes its pricing on its website and offers a feasibility study so you can confirm scope before committing. Compare what each fee covers, not just the headline number.

Schedule a Feasibility Study

Book your integrated feasibility study for unbiased, expert advice from our Architectural and Structural Engineers. Cost From £80

Feasibility Study Request

Related Articles

Feasibility Study for Commercial Property Renovation Guide

Check whether a feasibility study for commercial property renovation is worth doing before you commit. Get a clear go or […]

7 Garage Conversion Costs and Approval Steps Explained

Garage conversion costs, building warrant steps and timelines explained clearly. Then see which checks to run first so you avoid […]

How to Get a Building Warrant in Fife: Step by Step

Learn how to get a building warrant in Fife, from preparing drawings and documents to applying online, paying fees and […]